Best Italian Food in Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY

Authentic Italian Cuisine Made Fresh, Shared With Joy

Order online

Featured

View menu

Prosciutto Arugula Pizza

Burrata Pizza

Buffalo Wings

Caesar Salad

Smoked Salmon Pala

Welcome to Black Oak On Fifth

Since opening in 2022, Black Oak On Fifth has become a neighborhood favorite in Park Slope. Our family-friendly space is built around honest cooking and a relaxed atmosphere. From handmade pastas to wood-fired pizzas, our menu is crafted in-house with quality ingredients that bring people together around the table.

Pasta Tuesday

Join us every Tuesday for our irresistible Pasta Tuesday special! Enjoy all pastas for only $14, and indulge in our exquisite Calamarata Seafood pasta for just $16. This offer is available for dine-in only, so gather your friends and make it a night to remember. Don’t miss out—let's make Tuesday your favorite day of the week!

Savor the Menu

Experience a thoughtfully curated menu with highlights like Short-Rib Tagliatelle, Limoncello and Ricotta Ravioli, and Pappardelle Bolognese. From Margherita Pizza to Burrata Pizza, every dish is made with care, celebrating authentic Italian flavors. Specials such as Potato Tartare and Pulla Chili Wings offer unique tastes crafted by Executive Chef Misael Alvarez.

Explore Our Menu

Order Online with Ease

Enjoy your favorite dishes from home with convenient online ordering. Choose from classics like Black Oak Burger, Chicken Parmigiana, or Galli Sandwich. Whether it’s a pasta, pizza, or salad, every dish is prepared fresh, ensuring you can experience traditional Italian cuisine anywhere.

Order Now

Gallery of Flavors

From Calamarata Seafood to Tri-Color Peppercorn Tortellini, our dishes are visually vibrant and freshly prepared.

Reserve Your Spot

Secure a table to enjoy favorites like Eggs Purgatory, Black Oak Pancakes, or Frutti di Mare. Dine in to experience a menu filled with handmade pastas, pizzas, and carefully crafted entrees, all served in a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere that invites conversation and connection.

Reservation

Private Events

We have many choices for your event. From Open Bar Packages to Buffets.

Get in Touch

Dine-In Experience

From Pasta Tuesday specials to weekend brunch favorites like Eggs Benedict and Avocado Toast, our dine-in service celebrates authentic Italian-inspired dishes. Fresh pastas, pizzas, and entrees such as Black Oak Burger and Chicken Parmigiana are served in a friendly, family-focused setting designed for comfort and connection.

Visit Us 📍

Come to 200 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11217, to explore our menu firsthand. Hours of Operation: Monday–Thursday: 4 pm–11 pm Friday: 3 pm–11 pm Saturday: 10 am–11 pm Sunday: 10 am–10 pm Enjoy seasonal specials, handcrafted pastas, pizzas, and entrees like Lamb Shank with Saffron Risotto or Spicy Sausage Cream and Asparagus Pala, all served in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.

What our guests are saying

Excellent place came her for a daddy daughter date two years ago and their pizza was delicious and the I had a pappardelle that was awesome. Then just yesterday we ordered pizza that was Gluten Free, rice flour is the base and it’s freaking delicious

Patrick P.

We really enjoyed our food here. The pancakes were out of this world and the pizza was also great. Drinks were also yummy and were cheap during happy hour

Mia P.

I was taken here for my birthday dinner and had an absolutely wonderful experience. The staff was amazingly helpful, friendly, and kind and made some great drink and appetizer recommendations. The food was spectacular and I especially recommend the lobster ravioli, meatball appetizer, and buffalo chicken sandwich. The cocktails were also really great. Overall I couldn’t recommend the Black Oak on Fifth more for anyone looking to have a lovely dinner.